Colour Theory
Most people arrive knowing the family before they know the colour — "something grey", "a warm white", "a green but not a minty green". That is a perfectly good place to start. What follows is how each family actually behaves on a wall in a Toronto house: what the light does to it, where it goes wrong, and the colours in it we get asked for most.
Every colour here can be mixed into any Benjamin Moore line we carry, in any sheen, at either store. If you would rather search all 3,739 colours by name or number, use the Colour Finder.
The swatches below carry Benjamin Moore's own colour values, but a screen is still a screen — brightness, colour profile and the light in your own room all shift them. Use these to find your family and build a shortlist, then look at the real fan deck in the store. Beside each colour is its LRV, the light reflectance value: 90 is about as bright as paint gets, and anything under 20 will noticeably darken a room.
Whites & off-whites
The hardest family in the store to choose from, and the one people most often get wrong. A white is never just white — every one leans warm, cool, green or pink, and you only see which way once it is up on the wall next to your floor. A cool white beside warm oak reads grey and unfinished. A warm white beside grey-toned tile reads yellow.
The number to watch here is LRV, the light reflectance value. Chantilly Lace at 90 is about as bright as paint gets and will bounce daylight around a dark hallway. Pale Oak at 69 is technically still an off-white but behaves like a soft neutral on a big wall. Two whites four points apart can look identical on a chip and completely different across a whole room.
What we ask you: what colour are your floors, and is your trim staying white? Those two answers cut this list in half before you have looked at a single chip. Bring a piece of your flooring in if you have an offcut — it is the single most useful thing you can carry into a paint store.
Greys & greiges
A true cool grey can go cold and slightly blue in a north-facing Toronto room, especially between November and March. That is why most of what we sell now is greige — grey with enough warmth in it to hold up on a grey afternoon. Revere Pewter is the one people name without knowing it; Edgecomb Gray is the same idea a few shades lighter.
The rule of thumb: warm floors and warm furniture, go greige. A room that is already cool throughout — grey tile, chrome, cool white trim — and a true grey like Gray Owl will look deliberate rather than flat. Go deeper than about LRV 25 and grey stops being a background and becomes the feature, which is exactly what you want on a den or a set of built-ins.
Most common mistake: picking a grey off a phone screen in the evening. Every grey has a hidden undertone — green, blue or violet — and it only shows up in daylight, at scale, next to the things already in your room.
Beiges, tans & neutrals
Back in a serious way, and far better resolved than the yellow beiges of twenty years ago. These do the quiet work — hallways, stairwells, open-plan rooms where you want warmth without making a colour statement. They are the natural partner to oak floors, brass hardware and anything wood-heavy, which describes most houses in this part of the city.
Manchester Tan and Shaker Beige are the two we sell most of. Pashmina and Alexandria Beige are where the family gets deeper and more interesting — still a neutral, but with enough body to carry a whole main floor.
Worth knowing: a beige that reads perfectly balanced under showroom lighting can pull distinctly yellow under warm LED bulbs at home. If your lighting is warm, test at night before you buy the gallons.
Blues
Pale blues read cold in a north-facing room and lovely in a bathroom with a window — same colour, opposite result, purely because of where the light comes from. At the deep end, navy is the safest way to do a dramatic room: it behaves like a neutral, it sits well with wood and brass, and it is far and away the most requested colour we get for kitchen islands, built-ins and front doors.
Hale Navy is the one everyone means when they say navy. Van Deusen Blue is slightly softer and slightly more blue; Newburyport Blue sits between them. At the pale end, Palladian Blue and Wythe Blue both carry a lot of green, which is why they feel calm rather than cold.
If it is going on cabinetry: ask us about ADVANCE. It levels out brush marks as it dries and cures properly hard, which matters enormously on doors and drawer fronts that get handled every day. Wall paint on cabinets is the most expensive shortcut in home renovation.
Greens
The family that has changed most in the last few years. Sage and soft grey-greens have taken over from grey in bedrooms and kitchens, and deep forest greens are doing for cabinetry what navy did five years ago. October Mist and Saybrook Sage are the two we reach for most often.
Green is also the most light-sensitive family we sell. A sage that looks perfect at our counter can go grey in a north-facing room or turn faintly minty under cool bulbs — the pigments that make a soft green are exactly the ones that shift. This is the family where sampling is not optional advice, it is the whole job.
Always sample greens. Two patches, two walls, two days, and look at them at night under your own lights. We have never once regretted telling someone to do this, and we hear about the repaints from the people who did not.
Blacks & charcoals
Rarely a whole room, constantly used — doors, window frames, railings, a feature wall, exterior trim. A soft black with brown or blue underneath it looks expensive and has some depth to it; a flat true black can read as a hole in the wall. Wrought Iron is the workhorse here, and it is technically a very deep blue-grey rather than a black, which is exactly why it looks so good.
All of these sit at LRV 5 to 15, which means they absorb almost all the light that hits them. Good on a small cosy room, hard work in a room you actually need to see in.
On exterior metal and railings the product matters more than the shade. The wrong coating on outdoor metal will fail within a couple of seasons no matter how good the colour is. Tell us what the surface is before you pick the black.
Reds & pinks
Almost always a front door, a dining room, an accent wall or a piece of furniture. Reds are the hardest colours in the shop to get full coverage from — a strong red usually needs a grey-tinted primer and three coats, and skipping the primer is precisely how people end up with a patchy wall and a wasted weekend.
At the soft end, a blush with plenty of grey in it — First Light, Pink Bliss — behaves like a warm neutral rather than a pink, and it is one of the nicest things you can do to a bedroom or a powder room. Test those at night too: the blushes that look sophisticated at noon can turn sweet under warm bulbs.
Tell us the red before you buy anything else. We will set the primer up in the right tint for that specific colour, which is the difference between two coats and four.
Yellows & golds
Used far more on the outside of a house than inside these days. Indoors, a soft buttery yellow warms a dark kitchen or a basement stairwell in a way no white can manage — it gives back warmth rather than just reflecting whatever little light is there.
Keep strong yellow out of a south-facing room. Afternoon sun effectively doubles it, and a colour that looked cheerful on the chip becomes overwhelming by four o'clock.
Good use for this family: a windowless basement stair or an interior hallway. Those are the two places we most often steer people away from white and towards a soft yellow or a cream.
Rusts, browns & mauves
Rarely asked for by name, and often exactly what someone means when they say they want the room to feel warm. Terracotta and rust work beautifully on one wall, in a hallway, or on furniture, and they sit naturally with the wood tones in most Toronto houses. They photograph badly and sell themselves in person, which is why almost nobody arrives asking for them.
Greyed-off mauve is the surprise of this group. Shadow reads as a deep warm grey most of the day and only shows its purple in certain light — the same unpredictability that makes it interesting is why it is the colour we most insist you sample.
If what you want is a brown floor, door or trim, that is a stain question, not a paint question. Bring in an offcut of the actual wood and we will match on that — the same stain looks nothing alike on oak and on pine. See colour and stain matching.
Then come and see them properly
Narrow it to three. More than three and you will go round in circles, and a screen is for narrowing down, never for deciding.
Then tell us where it is going — which room, which surface, how much traffic, what sheen you want, and what state the wall is in right now. Stains, patches, damage, a bathroom that keeps growing mould. The colour is only half the decision; the product and the sheen are the other half, and a busy store will hand you whatever can is closest. We would rather ask you five questions first, because the wrong product is a whole weekend you do not get back.
The collections — and which fan deck to ask for
Every colour above lives in one of Benjamin Moore’s collections. They are grouped not by price or quality, but by how the palette was built and what it is good at — and any colour in any of them can be mixed into any line we carry, in any sheen. The collection you browse does not limit the paint you end up buying. It just changes how you find the colour.
The colour bars above are decoration, not swatches. No screen shows paint accurately — a colour that looks right on your phone at night can be a different colour on a wall in daylight. The fan decks in the store are the only reliable way to look at these.
How to choose without wasting a gallon
1. Start with the fan deck, not the internet
We keep the full decks in both stores and you are welcome to sit with them for as long as you need. If you want your own, we sell the Colour Preview fan deck and the Colour Collection fan deck.
2. Narrow it to three, then sample
Three is the right number. Paint a patch of each one big enough to stand back from, and leave it up for a couple of days — look at it in the morning, and again at night under your own bulbs. North-facing rooms and warm LED lighting are where colours turn on people.
3. Tell us where it is going
This is the part that matters most, and the part most people skip. Which room, which surface, how much traffic, what sheen you want, and what shape the wall is in right now — stains, damage, patches, a bathroom that keeps growing mould. A busy store will hand you a can of whatever is closest. We would rather ask you five questions first and give you the right product, because the wrong one is a whole weekend you do not get back.
4. Sheen is half the decision
The same colour in matte and in semi-gloss reads as two different colours. Our sheen guide explains where each finish belongs.
5. Matching something you already own
A wall colour with no name, a cabinet door, a tile, a cushion, an old stained baseboard — bring it in and we will match it. See colour and stain matching, often ready the same day.
Matching a colour you already have
An unnamed wall colour, a cabinet door, a tile, a cushion, an old stained baseboard — bring the piece in and we will match it. Bring the real thing rather than a photo; cameras and screens shift colour badly, and we cannot match from an image. For wood, bring an offcut of the actual wood you are staining. See colour and stain matching, often ready the same day.
Keep going
- Colour Finder — search all 3,739 Benjamin Moore colours by name or number, filter by family, and see every code and LRV.
- Sheen guide — matte, eggshell, satin, semi-gloss, and where each belongs.
- All our in-store services — colour matching, stain matching and more.
- Ready to buy: interior paint · exterior paint · stains · Fusion Mineral Paint
Come and see them on the deck
Richmond Hill — 11860 Yonge Street, Units 2 & 3, Richmond Hill, ON L4E 0W6 · 905-787-0707
North York — 6212 Yonge Street, Unit 103, North York, ON M2M 3X4 · 416-223-1780
Or message us on WhatsApp at (647) 227-1780 — tell us the room you are painting and what is already in it, and we will come back with three to look at.